Skip to main content
Version: 0.93

Sequence tagging: Extracting companies in financial news articles

We will demonstrate how to use Snorkel Flow to extract mentions of companies in financial news articles with state-of-the-art sequence tagging technology. In this tutorial, you will learn:

  • How to create a sequence tagging application
  • How to write labeling functions for sequence tagging application

Known limitations with sequence tagging​

The following items are known limitations and are planned to be added in future releases.

  • Tag-based analysis for arbitrary spans.
  • Applying tags to filter and adding comments happens at the document level instead of the span level.
  • Active learning.
  • Reviewer workflows in Annotation Studio.
  • Labeling function conflict in Studio data viewer filters.
  • Margin distance filter.
  • Advanced filters (composing with "OR," "ALL/ANY LF Voted")
  • Sequence Keyword LF supports at most ten keywords.
  • Sequence Fuzzy Keyword LF and Sequence Word Vector LF support at most three keywords.
  • Custom metrics are not supported

Create a dataset​

First, we will create a dataset named company-dataset by clicking on the “+ Add dataset” button in the Datasets page. Then we will add the following data sources for each split by clicking Add data source. Enter the two data splits below:

  • Train: s3://snorkel-financial-news/mini_train.csv
  • Valid: s3://snorkel-financial-news/mini_valid.csv

After adding these two data sources, click the “Verify Data Source(s)” button. Once the UID Column shows up, set it to index and add the data sources to the dataset.

For more information about uploading data, see Data upload.

Create an application​

Create a new Sequence Tagging application and fill out the fields as described below:

  • Choose working dataset: company-dataset (created above)
  • Application Name: company-ner-seq-tagging
  • Description: Sequence tagging application (optional)
  • Specify input schema: Click on text
  • Ground truth column: leave as blank
  • Negative label: OTHER
  • Labels: COMPANY
  • Seq field: text

seq_tagging_create_app_new.webp

Note that the Negative Label (OTHER in this case) is equivalent to the O (non-entity tokens) in BIO notation.

By default, a preprocessor TextSizeFilter is added in the DAG and filters out documents larger than 10 KB.

Adding ground truth​

Ground truth format​

Sequence tagging ground truth for a document is a JSON dump of a list of spans, where each span is a triple of (char_start, char_end, label). Here is an example label for a document:

json.dumps([
 [0, 29, 'OTHER'],
 [29, 40, 'COMPANY'],
 [40, 228, 'OTHER'],
 [228, 239, 'COMPANY'],
 [239, 395, 'OTHER'],
])

The spans cannot be empty (char_start must be smaller than char_end). Overlapping or duplicating spans are not allowed. The sets of char offsets (char_start, char_end) must be sorted.

Refer to snorkelflow.client.add_ground_truth() for how to infer negative labels automatically, providing positive labels only.

By default, a preprocessor AsciiCharFilter is added in the DAG and filters out the non-ascii characters from the documents. If you have ground truth that are collected outside of Snorkel Flow, please refer to snorkelflow.client.align_external_ground_truth() to align the ground truth before ingesting it into Snorkel Flow.

Upload ground truth file​

On the Overview page we get a high-level view of our application. We can also add any ground truth labels we have on this page. On the center of the dashboard you’ll notice a Upload GTs button. After clicking on it you’ll be prompted to provide the following information to import ground truth from a file:

  • File path: s3://snorkel-financial-news/aligned_mini_gts.csv
  • File format: CSV
  • Label column: label
  • UID column: x_uid

If you click on the View Active Data Sources button on the bottom left of the dashboard you can view the full set of data points and ground truth across splits:

 # of data points# of GT labels
train2000101
valid10086

In the sequence tagging application, each document is represented as a datapoint. The # of GT labels refers to the number of documents with one or more spans annotated with GT. We can now view our data by clicking the Go to Label button on the top right.

If you have external ground truth, but it does not have negative ground truth labels, please select Auto generate negative ground truth labels in Upload GTs page. The same option is also provided on the application creation page. Alternatively, refer to snorkelflow.client.add_ground_truth() to infer negative labels through SDK.

Annotate ground truth​

You can also annotate ground truth labels in the Label page directly by highlighting a span using either a double click or drag select mechanisms and assigning the label from the drop-down menu.

Note that in sequence tagging applications, one does not need to label negative spans explicitly. Once one labels any positive spans in a document, the remaining unlabeled text is labeled as negative (OTHER in this case) automatically. By default, the negative spans are not shown in the UI and are not counted towards the number of spans labeled on the top of the data viewer.

Write labeling functions​

LF builders for sequence tagging application​

Back on the Label page, you will notice two main panes:

  • The left pane for creating labeling functions and viewing labeling function statistics
  • The right pane for viewing the data

Here are some LFs you can try:

  • SKEY-facebook

    • Sequence Pattern Based LFs > Sequence Keyword Builder

      • text Contains a keyword in ["facebook"]

    • Label: COMPANY

    • Vote all the mentions of “facebook” as COMPANY

  • SRGX-Inc-Ltd-Corp

    • Sequence Pattern Based LFs > Sequence Regex Builder

      • text Contains the regular expression [A-Z]+[a-z]*,? (Inc|Ltd|Corp)\.?

    • Label: COMPANY

    • If a capitalized word is followed by “Inc” or “Ltd” or “Corp,” vote the whole phrase as Company

  • SRGX-Shareof

    • Sequence Pattern Based LFs > Sequence Regex Builder

      • text Contains the regular expression (?<=Shares of)\s([A-Z][a-z]+\s){1,5}

    • Label: COMPANY

    • Vote 1 to 5 capitalized words, as many times as possible, after the phrase “Shares of” as Company

  • SRGX-CEOCFO

    • Sequence Pattern Based LFs > Sequence Regex Builder

      • text Contains the regular expression \w+(\'|\’)?s? (?=(CFO|CEO|President))

    • Label: COMPANY

    • Vote the word before “CFO”, “CEO” or “President” as Company

  • SED-f500

    • Sequence Pattern Based LFs > Sequence Entity Dict Builder

      • text Contains the patterns from this file s3://snorkel-workshop-data/financial-news/f500_ticker_key_fixed.json
      • This file contains a dictionary of Fortune 500 company names, stock tickers, and their aliases.

    • Label: COMPANY

  • SRGX-lower

    • Sequence Pattern Based LFs > Sequence Regex Builder

      • text Contains the regular expression \b[a-z]+\b

    • Label: OTHER

    • Vote all the lower case words as OTHER

  • SRGX-wsww

    • Sequence Pattern Based LFs > Sequence Regex Builder

      • text Contains the regular expression \(\w+\)

    • Label: OTHER

    • Vote all the words in the parentheses, along with the parentheses as OTHER

  • SSPROP-adj-adv-verb

    • Sequence Pattern Based LFs > Sequence Spacy Prop Builder

      • If the tokens in this Spacy field doc is tagged with any of ADJ, ADV, VERB

    • Label: OTHER

  • SNER-DATE-PERSON

    • Sequence Pattern Based LFs > Sequence NER Builder

      • If the spans in this NER field doc is tagged with any of DATE, PERSON

    • Label: OTHER

LF metrics for sequence tagging application​

After saving an LF, you’ll see the score for that LF. Note that in the sequence tagging application, the metrics for LFs are computed at the character-level.

LF development with in-platform notebook​

The in-platform notebook interface allows you to develop custom labeling functions and explore your data using Jupyter. Here is an example of a custom LF. You can find details on other available helper functions in the Python SDK.

We can use the pre-defined dictionary derived from the 2016 Fortune 500 list to build a custom LF function to label all the Fortune 500 Companies as COMPANY:

from snorkelflow.studio import resources_fn_labeling_function

def get_taxonomy():
    import fsspec
    import json
    taxonomy_file = "s3://snorkel-financial-news/f500_ticker_key_fixed.json"
    with fsspec.open(taxonomy_file, mode='rt') as f:
        taxonomy = json.load(f)
    return {"taxonomy": taxonomy}
@resources_fn_labeling_function(name="lf_taxonomy", resources_fn=get_taxonomy)
def lf_taxonomy(x, taxonomy):
    import re
    spans = []
    for ticker, companies in taxonomy.items():
        pat = '\s(' + '|'.join(companies).replace('\\', '') + ')\s'
        for match in re.finditer(pat, x.text):
            char_start, char_end = match.span(1)
            spans.append([char_start, char_end])
    return spans

sf.add_code_lf(node, lf_taxonomy, label="COMPANY")

You can also create a multi-polar code LF (see Multi-polar LFs for more information) using the doc field that contains entity-level prediction from Spacy, e.g., if an entity is tagged as ORG, label the corresponding span as COMPANY, and if tagged as DATE, label as OTHER:

@labeling_function(name="my_multipolar")
def sample_multi_polar_code_lf_sequence(x):
    ents = x.doc['ents']
    spans = []
    for ent in ents:
        char_start = ent["start"]
        char_end = ent["end"]
        label = ent["label"]
        if label == 'ORG':
            spans.append([char_start, char_end, "COMPANY"])
        elif label == 'DATE':
            spans.append([char_start, char_end, "OTHER"])
    return spans

lf = sf.add_code_lf(node, sample_multi_polar_code_lf_sequence, is_multipolar=True)

Create a label package and label your dataset​

See the Create a label package and label your dataset of the Document classification: Classifying contract types.

Train a model​

You can train a model on any training set. For sequence tagging applications, we offer the DistillBERT model for its compactness and relatively fast training time while preserving 95% of BERT’s performance. If run on a CPU, this model may take several minutes or more to finish. We also offer BERT Tiny which is about 2x faster than DistillBERT while preserving 90% of BERT's performance. Additional details on models can be found in Model training.

Here are some details about parameters that are specific to Distillbert models:

  • fraction_of_negative_subsequences_to_use_for_training: Determines how many negative span tokens to show while training. This parameter helps reduce model bias for the negative label class when there is class imbalance between positive and negative label classes.
  • stride_length and max_sequence_length: These correspond to the transformer tokenizer parameters stride and max_length respectively.

Span, overlap span, and token level model metrics​

In the sequence tagging setting, we offer three levels of metrics to evaluate the final model performance:

  • Span level: Measures how many predicted spans match exactly with the ground truth spans based on character offsets.
  • Over Span level: Measures how many predicted and ground truth spans overlap more than 50% as measured by Jaccard similarity.
  • Token level: Measures how many predicted and ground truth tokens match exactly.

For example, given a ground truth span “Advanced Braking Technology Ltd” and a predicted span “Braking Technology Ltd,” our recall scores for each measure are:

  • span_recall = 0/1 = 0.0
  • overlap_span_recall = 1/1 = 1.0
  • token_recall = 3/4 = 0.75

View model predictions​

You can view the model predictions on the Label page. On the models pane, in the drop-down model selector menu, select the Model ID of interest, (e.g. “1”). This will change the span highlighting to be based on the model prediction. If you hover over individual spans, you can see the predicted class with the confidence associated with the prediction.

View errors and iterate​

See View errors and iterate in Document classification: Classifying contract types. Note that in the sequence tagging application, all analysis metrics are computed at the span level, which includes the Confusion Matrix, Clarity Matrix, Label Distribution, Class Level Metrics, Error Correlation, and PR curve.

Filters and span highlighting in record view and snippet view​

The filters are applied at the span level and automatically select the span type(s) to highlight among four types of spans (Ground truth, LF vote, Training set vote, and Model prediction). By default, ground truth is always highlighted. The spans matching the filter are presented in full color, whereas the spans that are not matching the filter are faded out in Record view.

In the Snippet view, the highlight control pane is not editable, but spans are still viewable by scrolling each snippet:

Correctness filter​

The correctness filter for LF and model/training set spans have different criteria. For model or training set spans to be correct, the exact match on both the boundary and label with ground truth is required. This is aligned with the span-level metrics. For LF spans, the correctness criteria is more relaxed: if an LF span only matches a part of a ground truth span, it is correct, as one can always write more LFs to cover the remaining part.

LF correctness filter​

An LF span is correct as long as it is a substring of a ground truth span with the same label. For example, in the screenshot below, both “Spring Bancorp, Inc.” and “Washington Bankshares, inc.” are correct.

An LF span is incorrect as long as it votes on any character that is not in the selected class. For example, the LF voted incorrect on the “acquired ” (whose ground truth is OTHER)

Model and training set correctness filter​

For a model or training set span to be correct, it has to match the ground truth span on both the label and the boundary. For example, in the screenshot below, only the first “Nvidia” and last “Nvidia” are correct model predictions and thus in focus. The second “Nvidia” is incorrect due to a mismatch in the span boundary and thus in transparent state.

There are three types of incorrect model/training set spans: (1) False negative (e.g., the second “McDonald,” the ground truth is COMPANY but model predicted OTHER) (2) False positive (e.g., in the second paragraph, the model predicted “s” as COMPANY, but the ground truth is OTHER) (3) a model prediction span has an incorrect boundary (e.g., the last two “McDonald’s”)

Dataset and application requirements​

  • Label classes: A maximum of 25 positive label classes can be specified
  • Labeling functions: A maximum of 200 labeling functions can be defined
  • Total dataset size: A maximum of 250 MB total text data (i.e., data in the text field) across splits can be specified
  • Studio dataset size: A maximum of 15 MB total text data (i.e., data in the text field) can be loaded in Studio
  • Each text field: The maximum allowable size for the text field in each data point is 10 KB

Please contact a Snorkel representative for recommendations if any of these limitations are a concern.